There are plenty of jazz fans who can't stand the lush and lazy sentimentality of arranger
Claus Ogerman. They think he's ruined it for every artist he's worked with --
Frank Sinatra and
Diana Krall to name two -- but they always seem to ignore that he was an integral part of at least one accepted classic,
Antonio Carlos Jobim's
Wave. He's also been responsible for a lot of cheese -- this or that orchestra plays the "hits of Italy" type albums -- and his work for
Andre Kostelanetz doesn't put him in a class with respected arrangers like
Ellington or
George Russell, and it isn't worth hearing anyway. That's why the well-picked American edition of
Man and His Music beats the four-disc
Man Behind the Music, released by the German Verve imprint Boutique (it also steals the too-big box's liner notes, which are insightful and mostly from the man himself). On the German release, you had to suffer a horribly suave cover photo of
Claus with a '70s suit and European cigarette -- held by the tippy-tip, of course -- but you also had to suffer too much
Streisand,
Michael Franks, and
Ogerman's own
Gate of Dreams album. Since this is a Verve-proper release, there are plenty of Verve's artists represented, which is fine, since it's with this label that
Ogerman did his best work.
Oscar Peterson,
Hank Jones,
Bill Evans,
Stan Getz, and
Wes Montgomery all succumb willingly to
Ogerman's sentimental aesthetic, one that's not really syrupy but is entirely formulaic. That's why it's up to the revolving door of guests to keep things interesting, and why three
Michael Brecker tracks are one too many (especially when they could have included the great
Getz/
Ogerman version of "Moonlight in Vermont"). A taste of
Freddie Hubbard's overly dated recordings with the arranger are, at the very least, time capsule interesting and
Diana Krall's "I Should Care" is a superb closer. The
Krall/
Ogerman album
Look of Love got whacked by the critics, but after a two-disc history lesson in the world of
Ogerman, it's possible to guess why the chanteuse turned to the arranger.
Ogerman makes fantastic mood albums, ones for rainy, sad days that are both wistful and warm. If you can relate a bittersweet breakup in
Krall's life to the recording date of her
Ogerman album, there you go. As far as the man himself, he's limited, but
Man and His Music respects what he has to offer and represents his talent splendidly.
–
David Jeffries, Rovi